How to Create an Online Marketplace Like Etsy (and Amazon or Airbnb)
How to create an online marketplace like Etsy: pick a niche, recruit your first sellers by hand, set up payments and choose a build route with real costs.
Kreezalidupdated 13 min read

Pick one narrow vertical, recruit your first sellers by hand, decide how you earn on each sale, set up split payments, then choose the build route that leaves you the most time for supply. With a hosted builder, the first version can be live in about 7 days. The software is the quick part; finding sellers is the slow part.
The audience is already there: in the EU, 78% of internet users aged 16 to 74 had bought online in 2025, up from 62% in 2015 (Eurostat, EU only, published February 2026, source). A share of it goes to the marketplaces that found their first sellers, not to the ones with the longest feature list.
Past this article already? The marketplace builder has a 14-day trial, no credit card.
Looking for the practical version for one platform? Each of these guides maps the model onto Kreezalid’s building blocks, in seven steps, with what you will and will not get:
- Build a marketplace like Amazon — a multi-vendor product marketplace
- Build a marketplace like eBay — second-hand between individuals, fixed prices and offers
- Build a marketplace like Etsy — a shop per maker, variants, reviews
- Build a marketplace like Airbnb — bookings, calendars, deposits, payouts
The short answer: how to build a marketplace like Etsy
- Choose a narrow vertical and name the transaction: what is exchanged, who pays whom, and when.
- Recruit the first sellers by hand, before the site is finished.
- Decide how you earn on each sale: a percentage, a fixed fee, or both.
- Set up payments that can pay many sellers, not one merchant account.
- Choose how to build it: agency, stand-alone builder, shop plugin or hosted builder.
- Launch with one category and the sellers you recruited, then widen.
What “like Etsy” really means
Codica, a software agency that publishes a guide on building an Etsy-like site, puts it this way: what sets Etsy apart from the rest is its vertical approach. It is a marketplace for handmade and vintage goods, where an Amazon-like site is horizontal and sells everything.
A plugin on an existing shop does not give you that. Shipturtle, which sells a multi-vendor app for Shopify, says as much in its own guide: the plugin route works best if your goal is an online mall, and not a platform where seller and buyer interact closely like on Etsy.
The shape of the network effect is also yours to choose. In a Sharetribe podcast recap, Casey Winters notes that Etsy’s network effect is wherever it can ship, while a hyper-local marketplace has one that is a walk to lunch. Decide which one you are building before you pick a template; niche marketplaces and online marketplace examples show how others drew that line.
Etsy’s numbers disagree, so this guide uses none of them
Look up how many sellers Etsy has and you get a spread. Dokan reports 8.3 million sellers in 2023. Shipturtle gives 7.5 million sellers and over 95 million active buyers as of the same year. A 2019 Bagisto post says more than 2.1 million active sellers as of 2018.
These are secondary sources from companies that sell marketplace software, with different dates and no shared definition of “active”. Use your own numbers instead: how many sellers you can name, and how many you can reach this month. For the same reason, this guide quotes no Etsy fee percentage: the pages we collected disagree, and none comes from Etsy.
Step 1: choose a narrow vertical and name the transaction
The first piece of advice in that Sharetribe recap is to start small or constrain your marketplace. The recap says it cannot be stressed enough. In practice that means one category and one kind of seller. Two audiences at once is two launches; we wrote about why you cannot chase two rabbits.
Name the transaction in one sentence: “Independent makers sell finished pieces to buyers, the buyer pays on the site, the maker is paid after delivery.” Writing it down forces decisions you would otherwise take by accident: who pays whom, when the money moves, what the marketplace keeps.
Check that the model fits a type the platform covers. Kreezalid covers six: services, rental, products, directory, peer-to-peer and B2B. An Etsy-like is a products marketplace, with sellers who are often individuals or very small makers; the pages on product marketplaces and peer-to-peer marketplaces describe the two nearest fits. The full method is in how to create a marketplace, and who to target first covers the order of recruitment.
Step 2: recruit the first sellers by hand
This is the part the competing guides skip, and it is the part of Etsy’s story that you can copy at no cost.
According to Codica, Etsy solved its chicken-and-egg problem by sending representatives to arts and crafts fairs in the US and Canada. Dokan adds that Etsy formed partnerships with online craft forums such as Craftster and Get Crafty. It also says Etsy initially launched its marketplace without requiring payments. The first sellers came from where makers already gathered.
The Sharetribe recap makes the same point: you can fake supply in the beginning. One founder in it, Encore, did not show suppliers to customers at all and used an inquiry form instead of a search page. The marketplace was real for the buyer; the matching was done by a person.
Your own version: help early sellers write their first listings, feature them on the home page, and treat each one as a customer you serve personally. More on this in how to onboard sellers on your marketplace.
What to do before you build anything
- Write down the places where your sellers already gather: a forum, a fair, a group, a trade body. Pick one.
- Ask them what stops them selling more today. Their answers become your first listing form.
- Enter a handful of listings yourself, with the seller’s agreement, and show them to a few buyers by email. If nobody replies, a better site will not fix it.
- Note which sellers would list again. Those are the ones you launch with.
No number here is a target: nothing we collected sets one. The chicken-and-egg ideas and the notes on online communities go further.
Step 3: decide how you earn on each sale
You set the rule and you can vary it by seller. Dokan’s Etsy-like guide gives the two shapes: a percentage, such as 10%, or a fixed fee, with different rates for different sellers. Ten per cent is Dokan’s example, not a recommendation.
The payment layer decides what is possible. Stripe Connect offers two models: Stripe handles pricing for your users, or you handle pricing and can collect fees from your users to earn revenue on every transaction. The second is the one a marketplace uses when it wants its own commission.
This article does not state Kreezalid’s commission rules; ask on the demo call before you plan your margins. For the thinking behind the choice, see marketplace pricing strategy.
Step 4: set up payments for many sellers
A shop takes money into one account. A marketplace takes money from a buyer, splits it between a seller and you, and pays the seller later. That needs a provider built for it.
On Kreezalid, Stripe Connect and Lemonway are built in, and Mangopay is available on request. Here is what we can say about each, and what we cannot.
| Provider | How it is offered on Kreezalid | What the source says about price |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe Connect | Built in | Two models: Stripe handles pricing, or you do and can collect fees on each transaction |
| Lemonway | Built in | Price not collected for this article; ask the provider |
| Mangopay | On request | No fixed public tiers or free plans; custom, volume-based pricing |
We quote no Stripe amounts. The pricing page we collected was served in Canadian dollars and is undated, and converting those figures would be guesswork. Check the pricing page for your own country.
Mangopay describes itself as an EU-licensed e-money institution operating since 2013, but expects a quote based on volume, which you will not know before launch. That is a reason to start on a provider with public pricing.
More on the choice in marketplace payment solutions and on the payments page.
Step 5: choose how to build it
Four routes exist. Read the table first, then the trade-offs.
| Route | Suits | What it costs | What it does not do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Custom build with an agency | A marketplace whose difference is the software itself | About $57,400 (Codica estimate) or around $50,000 (Shipturtle claim) | Leave much money for finding sellers |
| Plugin on a shop (Shopify, WordPress) | A retailer adding third-party sellers to an existing shop | Depends on the plugin; not collected | Give you a place where sellers and buyers interact closely (Shipturtle’s own words) |
| Stand-alone builder | A founder who wants a faster start than custom code | Not collected for this article | Customise as far as custom code (Shipturtle’s description) |
| Hosted marketplace builder | A founder whose edge is supply, not software | Kreezalid: from EUR 39 a month | Everything you can think of; see the limits below |
Custom build with an agency
Codica says that for complex projects, you build a custom website. Its Etsy-like estimate is $57,400, based on 1,148 hours at $50 an hour, which it says is the average rate of Eastern European agencies. Shipturtle says that outsourcing an Etsy-like site from scratch costs around $50,000 and takes a couple of months.
Both are vendor estimates, not market averages. The route suits you if the software is what makes your marketplace different. It suits you less if the difference is your community, because the budget that pays for code would otherwise pay for finding sellers.
A plugin on a shop
For a retailer who already runs a shop, a plugin is the shortest path: see Shopify marketplace and the WordPress option. For an Etsy-like, the limit is the one Shipturtle states: this is an online mall. We do not repeat the launch speed Shipturtle claims for its app, because we could not check it.
Stand-alone builders
Shipturtle groups Sharetribe and CS-Cart here: a faster launch with pre-built templates, but limited customisation, in its words. We have not collected pricing or feature claims from those vendors for this article, so we say nothing about what they charge or do. Our own comparisons, Kreezalid against Sharetribe and the wider list of platform alternatives, put the details side by side.
A hosted marketplace builder
This is what Kreezalid is. You start from one of more than 50 templates, pay a monthly plan from EUR 39, and the first version can be live in about 7 days. “About” is the word the product uses: it is a target, not a guarantee, and your own listings and content decide how close you get. The marketplace builder page and the templates gallery are the places to see what you would start from; the trial lasts 14 days and needs no credit card.
The limits matter as much as the speed. Kreezalid is a platform. What you want that it does not do has to come through its apps and API, or through a Plus or Enterprise project, both priced on quote. If your plan needs something built that no platform offers, the agency route is closer to what you want. Our build from scratch comparison sets out the trade-offs, and the no-code marketplace guide covers the route in more detail. See also best marketplace platforms.
Step 6: launch small, then widen
Open to the sellers you recruited in step 2, with one category, and keep registration closed or by invitation until buyers come back. Etsy’s own start was small: a first audience gathered at fairs and on forums, and no payments at launch.
Speed of build is rarely what holds a launch back; supply is. Widen when the sellers you have are listing without being asked; online marketplace growth covers what comes next.
What it costs: agency hours against a monthly plan
How much does it cost to start an online marketplace? The answer is a range, because the routes are different things.
| Route | Figure | Whose figure |
|---|---|---|
| Custom, Eastern European agency | About $57,400 (1,148 hours at $50 an hour) | Codica estimate, December 2025; not a market average |
| Custom, outsourced | Around $50,000 and a couple of months | Shipturtle claim |
| Kreezalid Build | EUR 39 a month | Kreezalid price list, checked 26 October 2026 |
| Kreezalid Launch | EUR 129 a month | same |
| Kreezalid Grow | EUR 299 a month | same |
| Kreezalid Extend | EUR 599 a month | same |
| Kreezalid Archive | EUR 19 a month | same |
| Kreezalid Plus and Enterprise | On quote | same |
Over 12 months (12 times the monthly price), the four main plans come to EUR 468 (Build), EUR 1,548 (Launch), EUR 3,588 (Grow) and EUR 7,188 (Extend). We do not add dollars and euros together, nor convert one into the other: the agency figures are in dollars, from vendors, and the plan prices are in euros, from us.
Payment-provider fees come on top of any route, and Plus and Enterprise are on quote, so no figure exists to compare. We give no Kreezalid commission or transaction-fee figure here.
Check storage against your catalogue: media storage is 500 MB on Build, 5 GB on Launch, 50 GB on Grow and 100 GB on Extend, and a handmade catalogue is photo-heavy. The cost breakdown and the pricing page go further.
Like Amazon, Airbnb or eBay: what changes
The method is the same; the first sellers and the model change.
Amazon
Amazon is the horizontal case, selling across every category, where Etsy is vertical. The matching route is a multi-vendor products marketplace; see how to create a multi-vendor ecommerce marketplace. What changes is the supply: you recruit by category, not by community.
Airbnb
If your model is Airbnb-like, you are building in the rental type, which the platform covers, on the rental marketplaces page and in the guide to the rental marketplace. What changes is what you seed: hosts offering dates, not sellers with stock.
eBay or Craigslist
Individuals selling to individuals is the peer-to-peer type. The page on peer-to-peer marketplaces and the peer-to-peer guide go through it. What changes is who you recruit: individuals, where they already trade.
We make no claim about the fees or revenue of these companies.
When not to build an Etsy-like marketplace
- You only want to sell your own handmade goods. You need a shop, or a listing on an existing marketplace. A marketplace needs other sellers, and you are not one.
- You cannot name your first sellers or reach them. No template fixes that. Etsy went to fairs and forums to find its first audience, and the Sharetribe founders’ advice is to start small.
- Your difference is proprietary software, such as matching, logistics or custom workflows. An agency build, or a Plus or Enterprise project on quote, is closer to what you need than a self-service plan. Kreezalid’s Build plan is not that.
- You are a retailer adding third-party sellers to a shop you already run. The plugin route may be enough, and Shipturtle says so itself: an online mall is what it suits.
If you are still weighing it, read this before you consider building a marketplace.
Frequently asked questions
How can I create my own online marketplace?
Choose one narrow vertical, recruit your first sellers by hand, decide how you earn on each sale, set up split payments, then pick a build route. On a hosted builder the first version can be live in about 7 days. The slower work is finding sellers, which you should start before you build anything.
How much does it cost to start an online marketplace?
It depends on the route. Codica estimates about $57,400 for a custom Etsy-like build from an Eastern European agency, at $50 an hour. Shipturtle says around $50,000. A hosted plan on Kreezalid is EUR 39 to EUR 599 a month, with Plus and Enterprise on quote. Payment-provider fees come on top of every route.
Can I create an online marketplace like Etsy for free?
You can try it free: Kreezalid’s trial lasts 14 days and needs no credit card. Running a marketplace is not free, since plans start at EUR 39 a month and payment providers charge their own fees. A free trial is enough to test a template, enter a few listings and show them to the first sellers.
Can I build an Etsy-like marketplace without coding?
Yes, with a hosted builder. You start from one of more than 50 templates and the first version can be live in about 7 days, a target and not a guarantee. What you give up is custom code. The no-code marketplace guide covers what that costs you and when it is a problem.
Which payment provider should I use for a marketplace with many sellers?
Use one built for split payments. On Kreezalid, Stripe Connect and Lemonway are built in, and Mangopay is available on request. Stripe Connect lets you collect fees on every transaction; Mangopay’s pricing is custom and volume-based, with no public tiers. Start with the provider whose prices you can see.
Try it on your niche before you commit
Open a 14-day trial on one of the templates, no credit card needed, and enter a handful of listings from the sellers you have already spoken to. If you want a second opinion first, book a 30-minute call with someone who has launched marketplaces and bring your transaction sentence from step 1.